Buyer’s Guide
Top 10 Ice Makers, Compared
Side-by-side specs from the 10 most popular ice makers on Amazon. Best-in-class numbers highlighted. Scroll horizontally on mobile.
| Smart score |
Item | Photo | Price | Buy | lb/24hr | Bin | Ice Type | Noise | Self-cleaning |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
#1 8.6
21,700+ reviews |
Silonn Countertop Ice Maker 26 lb/Day |  |
$79.99 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | ✓ |
|
#2 8.8
16,800+ reviews |
Frigidaire EFIC128 Compact Countertop |  |
$68.32 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | − |
|
#3 8.8
5,900+ reviews |
Silonn Ice Maker 8 Cubes / 6 Min |  |
$62.99 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | ✓ |
|
#4 8.8
5,200+ reviews |
Frigidaire EFIC101 Black Countertop |  |
$79.99 | Buy | 26 lb | 2 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | − |
|
#5 8.0
4,900+ reviews |
Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker EFIC237 |  |
$185.81 | Buy | 33 lb | 3 lb | Nugget | 40 dB | ✓ |
|
#6 8.0
4,900+ reviews |
Frigidaire Compact 26 lb/Day Countertop |  |
$89.98 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | − |
|
#7 8.6
3,700+ reviews |
Frigidaire EFIC123-SSBLACK Compact |  |
$59.99 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | − |
|
#8 8.6
1,500+ reviews |
Kismile Nugget Ice Maker Countertop |  |
$149.98 | Buy | 35 lb | 3 lb | Nugget | 40 dB | ✓ |
|
#9 8.4
1,200+ reviews |
Kismile Portable Ice Maker 26 lb/24H |  |
$89.98 | Buy | 26 lb | 1.5 lb | Bullet | 45 dB | − |
|
#10 8.6
1,100+ reviews |
Gevi V2.0 Nugget Pellet Ice Maker |  |
$379.99 | Buy | 38 lb | 4 lb | Nugget | 38 dB | ✓ |
■ Best in class · ✓ Yes · − No
The archive
Every gadget we’ve tested, ranked by what we’d actually buy.
